R.H. v. State, 2026 Ind. App. Unpub. LEXIS 955 (Ind. Ct. App. 2026)

The Indiana Court of Appeals reversed a delinquency adjudication of intimidation based on insufficiency of evidence involving a case of a 12-year-old who joked that she would bring a gun if her backpack wasn’t returned. The court stated in relevant part:

To adjudicate R.H. delinquent for acts of intimidation, as alleged, the State had to prove that she communicated to E.H. and K.S. a threat to commit a forcible felony with intent that E.H. and K.S. be placed in fear that the threat would be carried out. Ind. Code § 35-45-2-1(a)(4), (b)(1)(A). R.H. does not dispute that she communicated her shooting statement to E.H. and K.S. or that it constitutes a threat to commit a forcible felony under our intimidation statute. She argues only that the State failed to prove she made the statement with intent that E.H. and K.S. be placed in fear that the threat would be carried out—that is, that she would shoot them if they did not return her backpack.

 Intent is a mental function that is “determined from consideration of the defendant’s conduct and the natural and usual consequences of that conduct.” Matter of K.Y., 175 N.E.3d 820, 825 (Ind. Ct. App. 2021). In determining intent, the trier of fact typically must resort to reasonable inferences based upon an examination of the surrounding circumstances. Id. Here, the juvenile court found that R.H. was frustrated that her backpack had been taken and made the shooting statement to coerce either E.H. or K.S. to return it. From this, the court inferred that R.H. intended to accomplish the coercion by placing E.H. and K.S. in fear that she would shoot them if her backpack was not returned.

We do not find the juvenile court’s inference to be reasonable under the facts and circumstances of the case. Although R.H. had grown frustrated with the backpack prank and made the shooting statement in the hope that either E.H. or K.S. would return her backpack, nothing about the way R.H. made the statement or the circumstances surrounding it indicated that she intended her classmates to fear being shot. The videos show that R.H. did not raise her voice or make any sort of gesture when she made the statement. They also show that R.H. smiled immediately before and after making it and then resumed socializing and joking with her classmates. And, though not dispositive, E.H. and K.S. both testified that R.H.’s statement did not place them in any fear.

File Type: pdf
Categories: Court Decisions, Resource Library
Tags: Evidence, Mens Rea, Schools, Threats