Lowering the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: Consequences for Juvenile Crime

This study analyzes a Danish reform that temporarily lowered the minimum age of criminal responsibility from fifteen to fourteen between July 2010 and March 2012. Using nationwide administrative and police records for 162,959 youth, the study compared offending rates among fourteen-year-olds before, during, and after the reform.

From the Abstract:

Objectives: The questions of when and how society should sanction juvenile offenders are subject to ongoing political and scientific debates. In this study, we use a policy reform that lowered the minimum age of criminal responsibility from 15 to 14 years for a 20-month period to investigate whether lower age limits of prosecution and conviction in the legal system affect juvenile crime.

Conclusions: The age limits in the legal systems vary greatly across different jurisdictions and political discussions of when juvenile offenders should enter the criminal justice system are enduring. The findings from this study highlight important policy implications as the “tough-on-crime” motivated reform did not have the intended crime-reducing effects.

File Type: pdf
Categories: Research, Resource Library
Tags: Adolescent Development, Age as Mitigation, Age of Jurisdiction, Culpability, Data Collection and Analysis, Minimum Age of Prosecution, Rearrest or Recidivism