Diversion
This annotated bibliography was created as a part of the Transformative Policy Initiative, providing research, data, law articles and reports on setting a minimum age of jurisdiction and expanding the upper limit of juvenile court jurisdiction.
This annotated bibliography was created as a part of the Transformative Policy Initiative, providing research, data, law articles, reports, and alternatives to detention for youth defenders and advocates representing children charged with gun offenses.
From the Abstract: This Article will examine the critical role of pre-court diversion in the juvenile justice system and the traumatic impact that formal court referral has on children. Although juvenile proceedings are often described as rehabilitative rather than punitive, the act of being referred to court itself can produce lasting harm. Children who must…
This guidebook from National Conference of State Legislatures provides information on current youth justice policy at the federal and state level exploring a range of youth justice policy areas rom age of juvenile court jurisdiction and transfer into adult court to diversion and probation. From the introduction: “Today, a sound body of youth justice law…
From the abstract: Growing evidence on the collateral consequences of youth incarceration, combined with increased attention to developmentally appropriate and trauma-informed care, has advanced national reform efforts aimed at rethinking youth confinement. While attention to trauma-informed care and developmentally appropriate approaches within juvenile justice systems is important, the structural barriers inherent in secure settings limit…
From the Abstract: “Trisha was first incarcerated in a youth detention facility when she was just thirteen years old. Her first case, which occurred at age twelve while she was living in a group home, followed a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder resulting from years of sustained sexual, physical, and emotional abuse. Her charge, aggravated…
This infographic series on advancing best practices in youth justice from the RFK Community Alliance’s National Resource Center for the Transformation of Youth Justice provides accessible research on core practices driving change in youth justice and includes research on adolescent development and emerging adulthood, positive youth development and growth-focused case management, the negative effects of…
From the abstract: “Among the constellation of actors who appear in courtrooms every day, probation has been largely overlooked in conversations and debates about institutional reform in the criminal legal system. Prior scholarship has focused on probation’s role in administering the sentence of probation. This Article calls for recognizing probation as a key institutional player…
This report from the Sentencing Project provides an overview of restorative justice (‘RJ’) diversion programs including research on the results of these programs, the advantages of RJ diversion programming over court involvement, benefits to victims, and recommendations for implementing RJ programs. From the Executive Summary: “Restorative justice (RJ) diversion programs address adolescent lawbreaking outside the court system using a process designed to address victims’ needs and repair the harm caused by youth misconduct.…
This analysis by R Street highlights the need for states to establish a minimum age of arrest and minimum age of juvenile court jurisdiction. From the analysis: “Arresting elementary schoolers is traumatic, expensive, and ineffective, yet the question remains: How do we meet unmet needs without utilizing law enforcement? The answer lies in shifting from…
The National Institute for Criminal Justice Reform released a report spotlighting promising examples of credible messenger and intensive life-coaching programs to reach youth charged with serious offenses. “This brief argues that the next phase of youth justice reform must focus on intentionally and effectively serving HR2 youth. Doing so will require moving beyond strict replication…
This article from the American Psychological Association examines a September 2025 proposal from the House of Representatives in the District of Columbia that would allow fourteen-year-olds to be charged as adults and assesses whether such policies improve public safety. The author briefly reviews psychological and developmental research concerning adolescent development, the harms of prosecuting youth…
“The non-punishment principle is a legal norm that has increasingly gained legitimacy over the past quarter-century within international, regional, and domestic law on human trafficking. At its core, this principle opposes the punishment of human trafficking victims for unlawful conduct they engage in as a consequence of their trafficking victimization. Little is known about the…
The Sentencing Project released an updated snapshot of the numbers of youth in the juvenile legal system from 2000 to 2023, finding significant declines in youth arrests and incarceration, though racial and ethnic disparities persist. The report calls for the need to continued shrinking the juvenile legal system by increasing informal or diversionary responses to youth arrests. Introduction: “Youth arrests and incarceration increased dramatically in the closing…
This report from Vera Institute for Justice provides examples of reforms from various states that are working to reduce the incarceration of girls in detention and long-term placement. “Over the last decade, as a direct result of focused efforts by youth advocates and a growing body of research on developmentally appropriate practices, many states have…
From the R Street Institute: “Juvenile crime has captured headlines and consumed policymaking conversations in recent months. In fact, say six out of 10 major city mayors say juvenile crime is a problem in their city. But despite the temptation to “get tough” on all children who run afoul of the law, the research is clear: Harsher punishments, trying youth…
Provides tangible opportunities probation officers have to support positive youth development equitably for all youth, regardless of immigration status and circumstances beyond a young person’s control.
A companion checklist for probation officers, walking through key considerations when working with noncitizen youth.
From the Introduction: “Following a 2024 County Council request, the Pierce County Performance Audit Committee contracted with the CoLab for Community and Behavioral Health Policy at the University of Washington to conduct an audit of the county’s juvenile justice system against national and research best practice. The assessment is intended to guide future county investments…
From the Discussion: “This study illuminates pathways for future research to explore facility closures. Such research should investigate the impact of specific drivers supporting completed closures of youth facilities, including the combination of stated reasons to appeal to different audiences. Notably, we only found 1 paper in our scoping review that explores the strategies used…
From the conclusion” “Conclusion There is no question that the statistical picture of special education is bleak. But after its meeting of stakeholders, interviews with experts, and review of the research, NCD believes that IDEA and other related disability laws, with improved enforcement, can and should benefit at-risk students who are properly referred and served.…
The Sentencing Project released a report on adolescent gun possession cases, highlighting the harms of punishment and calling for comprehensive community-based initiatives to reduce gun violence. This report offers research on the reasons why youth carry guns, ranging from peer influence to past experiences of trauma and walks through how juvenile court systems typically respond…