Mens Rea

You must be logged into your Gault Center account to view this page.

Sample Motion to Adopt Reasonable Child Standard

Categories: , , ,

Felony Murder Affidavit of Patricia Coffey, Ph.D. and Odile Rodrik, M.S.

Categories: , ,

This affidavit relies on adolescent development research to conclude that felony murder should not be applied to youth, given that young people’s ongoing brain and psychosocial development goes against the very premise of felony murder. This affidavit emphasizes how felony murder perpetuates racial disparities and is contrary to adolescent development principles—namely that youth experience more…

Utah Toolkit for Representing Young People Charged with Sex Offenses

Categories: , , ,

From the introduction: “This project, which started in fall 2020, was initially intended to be significantly smaller than it turned out to be. Our coalition of authors intended to outline ways juvenile defenders could streamline their representation of youth charged with sex offenses. As the project gained momentum, this team of trial attorneys, social workers,…

Reckless Juveniles

Categories: , , ,

From the Abstract: “Modern doctrine and scholarship largely take it for granted that offenders should be criminally punished for reckless acts. Yet, developments in our understanding of human behavior can shed light on how we define and attribute criminal liability, or at least force us to grapple with the categories that have existed for so…

An Eighth Amendment Analysis of Statutes Allowing or Mandating Transfer of Juvenile Offenders to Adult Criminal Court in Light of the Supreme Court’s Recent Jurisprudence Recognizing Developmental Neuroscience

Categories: ,

From the introduction: ” Recent Supreme Court cases have recognized the science underlying the common-sense notion that children are not “little adults.” Their brains function in a completely different manner than those of adults. In 2005, the Court abolished the juvenile death penalty and recognized the neuroscience underlying the claim that those under the age…

Sample Motion Requesting Child-Centered Mens Rea Analysis

Categories: , , ,

A sample motion from Alabama requesting a child-centered mens rea analysis that recognizes the well-established differences between adolescent and adult thought processes and the effect that such differences have on an actor’s state of mind. This motion bases its argument for a child-centered mens rea on reasoning as articulated in recent United States Supreme Court…

Reply Brief, People v. Robinson

Categories: , , ,

In this reply brief, Chris Robinson, a young person tried as an adult in Colorado, challenges his conviction and sentence under Graham and Miller and makes a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel. The brief highlights in relevant part: “Because the Colorado parole process does not provide the juvenile offender with the full panoply of…

The United States Supreme Court Adopts a Reasonable Juvenile Standard in J.D.B. v. North Carolina for Purposes of the Miranda Custody Analysis: Can a More Reasoned Justice System for Juveniles Be Far Behind?

Categories: ,

Less Guilty by Reason of Adolescence: Developmental Immaturity, Diminished Responsibility, and the Juvenile Death Penalty

Categories: ,

From the introduction: “The authors use a developmental perspective to examine questions about the criminal culpability of juveniles and the juvenile death penalty. Under principles of criminal law, culpability is mitigated when the actor’s decision making capacity is diminished, when the criminal act was coerced, or when the act was out of character. The authors…

What’s Behind Behavior Matters: The Effects of Disabilities, Trauma and Immaturity on Juvenile Intent and Ability to Assist Counsel

Categories: ,

The delinquent act itself is often the primary basis for determining intention and competency of children under 18 in adult or juvenile court. But behaviors result from one or more of a diverse range of factors, each of which has different effects on decision-making. The capacity of juveniles to plan or to stop an action…