Transfer or Bindover or Certification
Click here to read the defense reply brief.
Click here to read the defense brief.
This position statement from Temple Center for Public Health Law Research reviews transfer mechanisms as an effective strategy in deterring crime and reducing recidivism among young people. Through reviewing the law, data and evidence, the Center for Public Health Law Research finds: “in the judgment of a Community Guide expert panel, there is sufficient evidence…
This brief highlights the United States Supreme Court’s most important language in landmark cases about young people’s rights. These quotes can be used to bolster the arguments and pleadings of juvenile defense attorneys and advocates as they defend youth caught in the legal system.
This article argues the Supreme Court’s recognition that children “are different than adults” creates a substantive due process right for every child to have an individualized assessment of their youthfulness at all critical junctures of a juvenile court proceeding, including transfer hearings. The article reviews transfer hearing statutes across the country and also analyzes fourteen…
The Kentucky Supreme Court found that competency attaches for young people at transfer hearings pursuant to the 6th and 14th Amendments of the U.S. Constitution as well as Section 11 of the Kentucky Constitution. The Court reasoned that because transfer hearings are critically important proceedings as identified in Kent, competence must be established before transfer…
From the Executive Summary: Florida prosecutes more children in the adult criminal justice system than any other state, and as a consequence, hundreds of children are held in adult county jails2 every year. In the majority of cases, the decision to prosecute a child as an adult is made by the prosecutor, without judicial review…
This affidavit written by Legal Ethicist Abbe Smith outlines the ethical quandaries posed by Florida’s direct file transfer laws and calls into question the legality of such laws based on adolescent development research. The affidavit states in relevant part: “The prosecutorial practice of direct file plea-bargaining without defender/child knowledge of the case’s strengths and weaknesses…
This report from Human Impact partners, CURYJ, and the California Alliance for Youth & Community Justice looks at the impact of transfer on young people in California using a Health Impact Approach (HIA). From the report: “This report evaluates the health and equity impacts of charging youth as adults in criminal court. Our goal is…
On December 14, 2016, the U.S. Department of Justice entered into a settlement agreement with the St. Louis County Family Court to remedy constitutional violations. The settlement agreement covers policies and practices to ensure the due process and equal protection rights of all youth are upheld. This includes early appointment of youth defense counsel, prohibition…
The New Jersey Supreme Court held the state is required to disclose all discovery in its possession to the child before waiving the child to adult court and offered the following language in support. “N.H. moved for full discovery before the waiver hearing, and the trial court granted the request. The court analogized the filing…
On July 31, 2015, the U.S. Department of Justice released its investigation findings into the St. Louis County Family Court, finding due process and equal protection violations. The findings include right to counsel violations by denying constitutionally adequate defense representation, privilege against self-incrimination violations by requiring a child to admit to allegations for diversion, inadequate…
From the report: Despite the strong language provided in the Prison Rape Elimination Act, state laws vary widely as to the regulations and parameters for housing youth in adult prisons. In fact, some states have no regulations or parameters governing the treatment of youth sentenced as adults at all. While some states have fully removed…
From the introduction: ” Recent Supreme Court cases have recognized the science underlying the common-sense notion that children are not “little adults.” Their brains function in a completely different manner than those of adults. In 2005, the Court abolished the juvenile death penalty and recognized the neuroscience underlying the claim that those under the age…
The Iowa Supreme Court struck down mandatory minimum sentencing schemes as applied to a young person transferred to adult court, finding mandatory minimum sentences to be in violation of federal and state prohibitions against cruel and unusual punishment and the best interest clause in Iowa’s juvenile code. The court notes “the statutory recognition of the…
This statement from the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry outlines their opposition to the direct file of young people into the adult system. From the policy statement: “The AACAP believes that any decisions regarding the transfer of a juvenile suspect to adult court should, at a minimum, involve an independent judicial review. Such…
This report from Human Rights Watch provides an overview of the impact of Florida’s direct file statute on youth tried as adults in the state. Additionally, the report contains recommendations to different systems practitioners and decisionmakers for ending the direct file practice. From the report: Florida transfers more children out of the juvenile system and…