Transfer or Bindover or Certification

Handbook for Practitioners: Representing Youth Charged as Adults in Superior Court

Categories: , , ,

This trial manual provides a roadmap for defenders representing young people who are facing transfer to adult court or have been transferred and charged as adults in Georgia Superior Court. The guide highlights relevant caselaw statutory analysis, research and studies on the harms of transfer to adult court, amicus briefs, motions, and developmental considerations for…

In Defense of Adolescence Worksheet

Categories: , , ,

This is a companion document for the “In Defense of Adolescence: Challenging the Constitutionality of Reverse Waiver and Transfer” Learning Lab from Summit 2026.

Forensic Exercise Sample Report- Transfer Learning lab

Categories: , ,

This sample expert report is for the transfer learning lab during Summit.

Forensic Exercise Fact Pattern- Transfer Learning Lab

Categories: , ,

This forensic exercise Fact Pattern is for the Transfer Learning lab.

Age of Jurisdiction Annotated Bibliography

Categories: , , ,

This annotated bibliography was created as a part of the Transformative Policy Initiative, providing research, data, law articles and reports on setting a minimum age of jurisdiction and expanding the upper limit of juvenile court jurisdiction. 

Harms of Transfer to Adult Court Annotated Bibliography

Categories: , , ,

This annotated bibliography was created as a part of the Transformative Policy Initiative, providing research, data, law articles and reports on the harms of transferring youth to adult court.

Crimes Against Humanity: The Mass Incarceration of Children in the United States

Categories: , , ,

This report from Human Rights for Kids gathers a national snapshot of the individuals who are currently in prison who were “prosecuted, convicted, and incarcerated for crimes they committed as children,” finding that the U.S. is currently incarcerating 32,359 individuals in prison for crimes committed as children. From the report: “The findings outlined in this…

Youth Justice: A Guidebook for Legislators

Categories: , , ,

This guidebook from National Conference of State Legislatures provides information on current youth justice policy at the federal and state level exploring a range of youth justice policy areas rom age of juvenile court jurisdiction and transfer into adult court to diversion and probation.   From the introduction:  “Today, a sound body of youth justice law…

The Childhood Trauma-to-Prison Pipeline: The Prosecution and Incarceration of Traumatized Children as Adults

Categories: , , ,

This report from Human Rights for Kids details survey results from 2,200 individuals who were incarcerated as adults for crimes they committed as children. The findings from the report demonstrate the fact that “children tried as adults are often victims long before they became [system-involved],” discusses the intersection between childhood trauma and the legal system,…

In re D.M., 2026 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 4700 (Cal. Ct. App. 2026)

Categories: , , , ,

The California 6th District Court of Appeal reversed a transfer order, clarifying that the prosecution bears the burden of proof to establish by clear and convincing evidence that a youth is not amenable to rehabilitation under the jurisdiction of juvenile court in order to transfer a youth to adult court. The court stated in relevant…

Commonwealth v. Harris, 2026 Pa. LEXIS 1133 (Pa. 2026)

Categories: , ,

A concurring statement in a Pennsylvania Supreme Court case highlights the need for expedited appeals related to transfer determinations. From the concurring statement by Justice Wecht: This problem reveals a challenging conflict of interests. There is nothing improper in the Commonwealth’s exercise of its right to appeal an adverse decertification order, and it should not…

Leveraging the State Constitution to Challenge Racialized Discretion in Washington’s Juvenile System

Categories: , ,

From the Abstract: In jurisdictions around the country, the criminal punishment system disproportionately impacts children of color at every stage: during arrest, diversion, and incarceration, and, most importantly for this Essay, during prosecution of children in adult court—which is among the most severely disproportionate aspects of the system. While the dominant narrative is that adult…

Youth Courts vs. Adult Courts: Why the Juvenile Justice System Works Better

Categories: ,

From the Sentencing Project: “Despite their many flaws, juvenile courts are better for youth who break the law than are adult courts. Contrary to critics’ beliefs, juvenile courts regularly address serious and violent crimes. Juvenile courts do not offer a “slap on the wrist;” they often issue harsh punishments. The frequent alternative, sending youth to…

Commonwealth v. Donovan, 497 Mass. 355 (Mass. 2026)

Categories: , , , ,

The Supreme Court of Massachusetts held that a transfer hearing is a “critical stage of the criminal process” that requires effective assistance of counsel under the 6th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The Court held that defense counsel’s failure to present evidence on youthfulness, developmental maturity, and rehabilitation prevented the judge from considering factors critical…

In re I.H., 2026 Kan. App. LEXIS 10 (Kan. 2026)

Categories: , ,

The Kansas Court of Appeals held that a youth may not be prosecuted as an adult if they were under the age of 13 at the time of the offense based on the court’s statutory interpretation of  K.S.A. 38-2347. The court stated in relevant part: “From this review, we do not find that the Legislature…

People v. O.F. 2026 LEXIS 149 (CA. 2026)

Categories: , , , ,

The California Court of Appeals First District reversed and remanded a trial court’s order transferring O.F. to adult court, finding that the trial court must make specific findings on a young person’s amenability to rehabilitation and must meet the heightened burden of proof. The court reasoned in part, “The recent amendments to section 707 have…

Youth Transfer

Categories: , , , ,

This one-pager from the Juvenile Law Center can be used as an educational tool for judges, policy makers, community members and other decision makers when talking about transfer to adult court. From the one-pager: “Policies that try children in the adult court system fail to consider the harms of youth transfer, the unique developmental characteristics…

Waging the Battle for Society’s Soul: the Constitutionality of Juvenile Transfer Legislation in the Wake of Jones v. Mississippi

Categories: ,

From the Note: Trying juvenile defendants as adults is a cruel, yet enduring practice in U.S. criminal law. If convicted, these youthful offenders face brutal conditions in adult prison and a lifelong stigma. Although these devastating consequences of conviction are readily apparent, juvenile transfer is insidious even absent a prison sentence or criminal record. State-level…

Time Out for Transfer: Youth Transfer as Punishment

Categories: , , ,

This law review article written by Professor Kristina Kersey explores transfer as a form of punishment and calls for jurisdictions to enact a moratorium on transfer, drawing lessons from the movement to end the death penalty. Noting similarities between transfer and the death penalty, this article analogizes the two and argues that transfer mechanisms operate…

State v. Mann-Tate, 2026 WI App 17 (Wis. Ct. App. 2026)

Categories: , , , ,

The Court of Appeals of Wisconsin held that the state’s reverse waiver statute was unconstitutional “to the extent it does not require circuit courts to consider the unique attributes of youth identified by the United States Supreme Court.” In Wisconsin, a youth’s case that is directly filed in adult criminal court may be sent to…

The Gault Center Letter in Favor of Maryland Senate Bill No. 323 Jurisdiction (Youth Charging Reform Act)

Categories: , , , , ,

This letter written and submitted to the Maryland Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee on behalf of the Gault Center, outlines its reasons for supporting Maryland Bill No. 323 (named the Youth Charging Reform Act), which would limit the types of cases eligible for automatic transfer to adult court. From the letter: “The Gault Center: Defenders of…

AB 1647 – Transfer Bill Proposed in California to Change Standard of Proof for Amenability Finding

Categories: , , ,

This proposed legislation from California amends the transfer law (CA WIC § 707(a)) to require a judicial finding of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, instead of the lesser standard of clear and convincing evidence, that a minor is not amendable to rehabilitation while in juvenile court. 

Sample Memorandum of Understanding Between Assistant District Attorney and Youth Dismissing Case in Adult Court and Agreeing to Special Conditions and a Negotiated Plea in Juvenile Court

Categories: , , , , ,

This sample memorandum of understanding from Louisiana outlines an agreement between the Assistant District Attorney and a youth who was transferred or direct filed in adult court to return to juvenile court with an agreed-upon plea and disposition. This is a tool defenders can utilize in advocating for a youth to be sent back to…

Should 14-Year-Olds Be Charged as Adults?

Categories: , ,

This article from the American Psychological Association examines a September 2025 proposal from the House of Representatives in the District of Columbia that would allow fourteen-year-olds to be charged as adults and assesses whether such policies improve public safety. The author briefly reviews psychological and developmental research concerning adolescent development, the harms of prosecuting youth…

People v. Michael J., 2025 IL App (5th) 250546-U (Ill. Ct. App. 2025)

Categories: , ,

The Illinois 5th District Court of Appeals found that the juvenile court lacked statutory authority to proceed on a transfer determination once a young person turned 22 years old. This case involved an initial transfer determination followed by a reconsideration request by the defense based on lack of probable cause to justify the initial transfer…